Allow one of Nantucket Grill's amazing pastry chefs to create your next dessert! We make our specialty cakes available to order in quarter, half, and whole sizes. Most are available with a 24 hour notice. We make all of our special order cakes half the height and twice the width as we serve in store (3 layers of cake with 2 layers of filling). This makes them easier to transport and to serve. We also offer customized sheet cakes.

Dreaming of a flavor you don't see in the store?
Just ask. We can make many more flavors upon special request. Gluten free, vegan, and sugar free options are also available.

Flavor of the Month

Please ask for this month's featured flavor

Strawberry Shortcake

Layers of moist vanilla cake filled with fresh strawberries and iced in freshly whipped cream

Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake

Chocolate cake layers filled with fresh strawberries and iced in whipped cream and drizzles of chocolate syrup
Available April - August in stores


Layers of vanilla cake filled with creamy coconut filling, iced in whipped cream, and topped with toasted coconut 


Layers of vanilla cake soaked with a flavorful blend of coffee and brandy then filled with a creamy mascarpone cheese filling, iced in whipped cream and topped with chocolate dust

Chocolate Bliss

Alternating layers of vanilla and chocolate cake filled with bits of dark chocolate and iced in whipped cream with drizzles of chocolate syrup 

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Layers of chocolate cake filled with creamy peanut butter filling then iced in chocolate buttercream icing topped with Reese's cups and peanut butter drizzle


Layers of vanilla cake filled with colorful buttercream icings, iced in vanilla buttercream, and topped off with sprinkles


Moist carrot cake iced in cream cheese icing and topped with chopped walnuts

Triple Chocolate

Moist chocolate cake layers filled with rich chocolate ganache filling and iced in chocolate butter cream icing

Red Velvet

Red velvet cake filled and iced in cream cheese icing
Available in stores in Raleigh and Chapel Hill


Layers of vanilla cake filled with a tart lemon filling and iced in lemon buttercream

German Chocolate

Layers of chocolate cake filled with a creamy coconut-pecan filling iced in chocolate buttercream and an accent of fudge icing
Available September - March in stores

Pina Paradise

White cake with a creamy pineapple, pecan, cream cheese filling and iced in whipped cream

Custom Sheet Cake

Do you need a celebratory cake for a Birthday, Anniversary, Baby Shower, Bridal Shower, Graduation or Holiday? Customized Sheet Cakes serving 12 to 55 people are available with a minimum of 24 hours notice. Choose from vanilla or chocolate cake with your choice of white buttercream, lemon buttercream or chocolate buttercream frosting.

Ready to place your order?

Order Now